By Melody Kinser
mkinser@mechlocal.com
Jessica Lee Sterling Hatch often walked from her Richmond home on West Grace Street to her grandmother’s on Hanover Avenue.
Making her way through the city’s Fan District was common for the 12-year-old. On Feb. 5, 1984, that would all change: Jessica went missing.
Her remains were found on April 12 of that year on Watkins Road in a rural, wooded area of Rockville in Hanover County. Information on the cause of death has not been released.
As the 27th anniversary of Jessica’s disappearance and death approach, Investigator Christopher J. Davis of the Hanover County Sheriff’s Office is now in his third year of pursuing justice for the pre-teen. He said he feels a unique connection to this case in that he was the same age as Jessica when she was taken.
It was around dusk, around 6 p.m., on that winter evening in 1984 when Jessica took off from the 2900 block of West Grace Street to the 3200 block of Hanover Avenue. The route she preferred had her traveling North Sheppard Street, a distance of 0.62 miles according to MapQuest.
MapQuest lists the journey from Richmond to that remote portion of Hanover County at a little more than 25 miles.
Davis said Jessica was reported missing the same day. “It was in the evening hours; it was early evening before dark, at dusk.” Her grandmother’s house was “several blocks away,” but, as the investigator said, “it’s within walking distance.”
“Her normal path,” he said, “was to take Sheppard Street. She was walking alone this particular evening.”
“We want to concentrate on the fact that she went missing between Grace Street and Hanover and Sheppard Street,” Davis said. “That was the path that she always would take.” He estimated it to be a five- to 10-minute walk.
“She was allowed to go by herself,” he said. That particular evening, Jessica wanted to have dinner with her grandmother.
Jessica was a student at Binford Middle School and played around the neighborhood where she went missing.
Capt. Michael J. Trice said the Sheriff’s Office is “reviewing previously collected evidence, working with the City of Richmond on this case right now. We’ve consulted with them,” he said of the Richmond Police Department. “We are reviewing the case file, re-evaluating information that’s been assembled so far, and seeking additional forensic examinations when possible.” Evidence collected at the scene is now available for new techniques.
“We are taking a fresh look at this case, Davis said, “we do not have any tunnel vision based on information that has been gathered previously.” “We’re dealing with facts,” Trice said. In 1984, media outlets reported on the possibility of ties to satanic or ritualistic rites in Jessica’s death.
“We are looking at every aspect of this case to maximize the information we can get,” Trice said. “Everything from identifying forensic techniques that did not exist in 1984 to preserving the evidence to be analyzed with future techniques. We have consulted with forensic experts to ensure everything that can be done is being done. To be sure there are no gaps in information collected, the same scrutiny is being applied to previously collected witness statements.”
“This has been going on for three years now,” Davis said, with him gathering information. He asks that readers focus on “where she was taken from and where she was found.” The road where Jessica’s remains were discovered is on a dead-end. Motorists travel to Oilville and come back into the Rockville area of the county.
The location, Trice said, “was sparsely populated then, and it’s sparsely populated now.” “It’s very out of the way,” Davis added.
“I think this case is solvable,” Davis said, “because we believe somebody has the information we need. We want to make sure people know we are ready to listen. We believe there is critical information still out there on this case that people have not disclosed to the police.”
“While those with information may not still be in the area, with articles like this being posted on the Internet we have a possibility of reaching those with information beyond just our market. Today’s technology can prove a beneficial tool in these cases,” Trice said.
The time frame of what happened from the time Jessica left her home to when her body was found has created “a lot of speculation and we’re obviously trying to fill that gap,” Trice said. “Some of the answers are where her body was recovered, and we’re still seeking evidence from that scene.”
The Sheriff’s Office, the captain said, is “still reaching out for answers to what happened when she went missing in Richmond city, and we do believe there are people out there that have additional information on this case and we’d like to talk to them.”
“There’s a better chance somebody saw something on Sheppard Street or Hanover and Grace,” Davis said, “and that’s what to focus on. Somebody may have seen somebody talking to her or her getting in a car.” His request is that anyone who may have seen or heard anything on that day to come forward.
Despite the number of years that have passed, as with all Cold Cases, Trice said their office continues to seek information. “We believe that there are people out there — whether Hanover [County] or City of Richmond — that have not provided information to the police.”
“We are still working on this case,” he said. “After 27 years we still remain committed to finding out what happened to Jessica and who was responsible for her death.”
“With the Jessica Hatch case,” Trice continued, “it’s not uncommon to get pieces of information on a case like this. That has kept this case on the desk for a long time and it’s talked about among the investigators here — people that are still working here,” referring to those in the office who were employed by the HCSO in 1984.
When Jessica disappeared from the city, former Hanover County Col. V. Stuart Cook was still working at the RPD. Having knowledge of the case, he made solving her murder a priority when he accepted the sheriff’s position here.
“We’ve been following up leads for some time and continue to work leads,” Trice said.
Davis echoed Trice’s statement about Cook’s interest in the case and said the same holds true for Col. David R. Hines, who succeeded Cook in the top law enforcement office last fall.
Like Cook, Davis said, Hines is committed to pursuing investigations of older crimes.
Davis carries with him the original folder Howard Wray, the primary investigator on the case in the 1980s, has compiled.
Since assuming responsibility for Jessica’s case, Davis has been working with Sgt. Max Matko of the Richmond Police Department. In the city, the investigation is being pursued as a missing person’s case, while it is a homicide here.
In the 1980s, Davis added, it was not unusual for a child to walk alone.
Jessica’s disappearance took place almost three years after “America’s Most Wanted” host John Walsh’s son Adam was snatched from a Florida store, prompting significant media attention on missing children.
Trice called Jessica’s disappearance and death “a crime of opportunity.”
“Whoever did this took advantage [of the situation] and took her,” he said.
At this point, no witnesses have come forward.
——-
Anyone with information pertaining to the disappearance and death of Jessica Lee Sterling Hatch is asked to contact the Hanover County Sheriff’s Office at 365-6110 or Crime Solvers at 780-1000.

Davis